If you love stories, you may already listen to Selected Shorts — either at Symphony Space, if you live in (or visit) New York, or on the radio (or streaming online), as I did for many, many years. There’s something so special about listening to someone read or tell a story, and I never outgrew the pleasure of it. One of my favorite memories is from the summer I had a new spinning wheel and I’d spin while Marnie read aloud to me — Grendel, John Gardner’s wrenching version of the Beowulf story, from the point of view of the monster. So a couple years ago, still relatively new to Manhattan and constantly dazzled by it, I bought an annual subscription to the Selected Shorts season, and loved going to all the performances. Now I pick and choose, and last night I went to the show called NOLA: Jazzy Tales from the Big Easy. I adore New Orleans, and have been there more times than I can shake a stick at. Here’s the program:

what a lovely menu!

Michael Cerveris
Of course the best part is sitting in the dark listening to the stories, and that’s worth the price of admission. But it’s also just fascinating watching the performers, some of whom perform. Some act the hell of out the piece. Some read it. Some are overly precise in their diction, some are loose and jangly. Michael Cerveris threw himself into reading the chapter from A Confederacy of Dunces, giving Ignatius a deep, slow booming voice, and the other characters quite different voices. He has a lot of familiarity with New Orleans (real being-there familiarity) and got the accents just right. There’s more than one accent there, and he nailed them, which gave me a lot of pleasure.

Patricia Clarkson, so luscious
Patricia Clarkson’s mother “runs New Orleans,” she said, and she grew up there. She’s got that deep, lush, drawly accent, you know, so I figured her readings would be great. She’s one who acted the hell out of it. Before she started, she suddenly took a wide, firm stance as if facing the microphone for a fight. When she started to read the Bukowski, she shifted her stance entirely. She was quite dramatic (big surprise there), raising and lowering the volume of her voice quite a bit, and her facial expressions were fluid and exaggerated. Sometimes I liked it, sometimes it felt a bit much, but I was definitely engaged. I just love hearing her accent, no matter what.

Clarke Peters -- loved him in The Wire, and also in Treme
Clarke Peters was gorgeous, elegant, and with such a deep beautiful voice it was a joy listening to him. I thought he was the best of the night. He really just stood there and told the story of the man trying to teach New Orleans kids how to play jazz, acting out what was necessary, singing the singing bits. He wasn’t flamboyant but he was in it. He also really nailed the accents, and I could close my eyes and listen to him and feel like I was back there. I could hear things that he wasn’t putting into the story, because what he did put into the story was so full. I wish he’d been the last reader of the night, it would’ve been such a lovely place to end. Unfortunately, he wasn’t.

Amy Ryan, loved her in everything she's ever done
I was so looking forward to Amy Ryan; she’s a Selected Shorts regular but I’ve never seen her. And Eudora Welty, come on. It was going to be great. At first, I thought it was. Amy Ryan read with a kind of clean precision that felt easy to listen to. But the story went on. And on. And on. And on. And on. You get the picture. It went on. I didn’t look at my watch, but her story lasted as long as all the others put together. It was just too long for that setting; on the way out, I heard all the people around me complaining about that too. It wasn’t enjoyable, and by the end I was just hating Eudora Welty. And I had so much time to listen to her read, I realized I didn’t like the way Amy Ryan approached reading the story — she was too cerebral. I can’t quite figure that out, because she used different voices for the characters, she used different volumes, she didn’t stand like a statue. But nonetheless, she was too cerebral and disconnected from the piece, and it didn’t help.
Still and all, it was a wonderful evening of intense story. Listening required great effort; it’s not at all a passive experience, even though it seems so. With each performer, the listener has to make a shift and learn how to hear. And listening to stories being read takes more effort, there’s a period of adjustment at the beginning where it doesn’t make sense — true of just reading short stories, too, sometimes.
And thus ends the first of my fantastic NY nights. Next up: Friday night’s Winter Solstice Concert at St John the Divine. It’s so delicious having such great things to look forward to.
Popular posts: